Class and Status

A goblet representing the theme of Class and Status in The Taming of the Shrew.

Theme Profile – At a Glance

  • Focus: How rank works in the play: who gives orders, who takes blows, and how much of a gentleman is his clothes. A tinker is made a lord and a servant a master, and almost nobody can tell.
  • Key Characters: Christopher Sly, the Lord, Tranio, Lucentio, Petruchio, Grumio, Katharina, Baptista, Vincentio.
  • The Core Tension: Padua believes that rank is a matter of birth. The play keeps showing that it is a matter of costume, money and confidence, and then puts everyone back where they started.
  • Key Manifestations: A tinker dressed as a lord (Induction); master and man change places (A1S1); servants beaten and abused (A1S2, A4S1); a gentleman’s daughter starved and dressed plainly (A4S3); a servant in silk denies his master (A5S1).
  • Famous Quote:
    "I am Christophero Sly; call not me 'honour' nor 'lordship:' I ne'er drank sack in my life..."
    (Induction, Scene 2)
  • The Outcome: The servant gives the cloak back and the fathers resume control. Only the tinker is left unaccounted for, still a lord when the text last looks at him.

By Birth a Pedlar

The play opens at the bottom of the social scale. Christopher Sly is a tinker, a mender of pots, drunk and in debt to an alehouse. A lord out hunting finds him asleep and decides, for sport, to see whether a beggar can be made to forget himself. Sly wakes in a silk bed with servants offering him wine and fine clothes, and his first reaction is to state exactly who he is.

Original
What, would you make me mad? Am not I Christopher Sly, old Sly's son of Burtonheath, by birth a pedlar, by education a cardmaker, by transmutation a bear-herd, and now by present profession a tinker?
(Sly, Induction, Scene 2)

Shakespeare Retold (Modern Verse)
What, do you think I’m mad? Aren’t I Christopher Sly, old Sly’s son from Burtonheath, by birth a travelling tradesman, trained as a wool toolmaker, then morphed into a bear keeper, and now I mend pots for a living?

Pedlar, card-maker, bear-keeper, tinker: he gives his whole career, and names the ale-wife who will vouch for him. It is the most precise account of a social position in the play, and he is proud of it. Within fifty lines he has given it up. Told that he has a beautiful wife, he decides he is a lord after all. The joke is partly on Sly, who goes on asking for small ale. It is also on the idea of nobility, which turns out to need only a bed, a servant and somebody to say "your honour". The theme of illusion vs reality starts from the same scene.

Man or Master

The pattern is repeated at once among the gentry. Lucentio, a rich merchant’s son, wants to enter a house as a tutor, and needs someone to be himself while he is away. He looks at his servant and sees no difficulty.

Original
We have not yet been seen in any house,
Nor can we lie distinguished by our faces
For man or master; then it follows thus...

(Lucentio, Act 1, Scene 1)

Shakespeare Retold (Modern Verse)
We haven’t yet been seen by anyone
And both our faces can’t be recognised
As master or as servant. So we’ll do this...

Nobody in Padua knows their faces, so nobody can say which is the man and which the master. That is a remarkable thing for a gentleman to admit. The only thing marking him off from Tranio is that people have been told. They exchange clothes, and Tranio spends the rest of the play as a wealthy suitor, bidding for an heiress, patronising her father and drinking with the gentlemen. He is more convincing in the part than his master ever was. The theme of disguise and deception supplies the costumes; what the costumes prove is that a gentleman can be imitated by anyone who has watched one closely.

Knock Me Here Soundly

If rank can be put on like a coat, it is also enforced with fists. Petruchio enters the play giving his servant an order and beating him for misunderstanding it.

Original
PETRUCHIO: Villain, I say, knock me here soundly.
GRUMIO: Knock you here, sir! Why, sir, what am I, sir, that
I should knock you here, sir?

(Act 1, Scene 2)

Shakespeare Retold (Modern Verse)
PETRUCHIO: You idiot, I said knock hard for me.
GRUMIO: Knock you hard here, sir? Why, sir, what sort of person would
I be if I knocked you hard, sir?

Petruchio means knock at the gate. Grumio takes it, or pretends to take it, as an instruction to hit his master, and asks who he is to do such a thing. He gets his ears wrung. It is a clown’s routine, and it sets out the rule: a master may strike a servant, and a servant may not even imagine striking back. At the country house the same treatment is handed out all round.

Original
Where be these knaves? What, no man at door
To hold my stirrup nor to take my horse!

(Petruchio, Act 4, Scene 1)

Shakespeare Retold (Modern Verse)
Where are those fools? What, no one came to greet me
To hold my stirrup nor to take my horse!

The servants are knaves, peasants, "whoreson" drudges; one is struck for pulling off a boot clumsily, another for spilling water. Petruchio is putting on a show of temper for his bride’s benefit, and the men seem to know it. But the blows are real, and the play takes it for granted that he is entitled to give them. The theme of power and control is built on this. Katharina is being shown how a household works, and where the authority in it sits.

A Silken Doublet

The play saves its sharpest collision of ranks for the fifth act. Vincentio, a real merchant of real wealth, arrives at his son’s lodging and sees his servant come out dressed like a lord.

Original
What am I, sir! Nay, what are you, sir? O immortal gods! O fine villain! A silken doublet! A velvet hose! A scarlet cloak! And a copatain hat! O, I am undone! I am undone! While I play the good husband at home, my son and my servant spend all at the university.
(Vincentio, Act 5, Scene 1)

Shakespeare Retold (Modern Verse)
Who do I think I am! No, sir, more like, who are you? Oh my God! Oh you villain! A silk jacket! A velvet hose! A scarlet cloak! And a pointed hat! Oh, I am ruined! I am ruined! While I’m behaving as a good husband at home, my son and my servant are spending all my money at university.

A silken doublet, a velvet hose, a scarlet cloak and a "copatain", a high-crowned, hat: he counts the garments like a man reading a bill. Part of his horror is at the expense. Part of it is at the sight of a servant in clothes that only his betters should wear. In Shakespeare’s England there were laws on the subject. Tranio’s reply is that the old gentleman must be mad, and for a moment the servant has the master on the point of arrest. Then Lucentio returns and order is restored. Tranio is forgiven and, in the last scene, sits at the wedding feast. The play has let a servant be a gentleman for four acts, and nothing in Padua fell down.

"He is very slow in giving up his personal identity in his sudden advancement."

— William Hazlitt, Characters of Shakespear’s Plays, 1817

Key Quotes on Class and Status

Quote 1

O monstrous beast! How like a swine he lies!
Grim death, how foul and loathsome is thine image!

(Lord, Induction, Scene 1)

Shakespeare Retold (Modern Verse)
Disgusting man! He’s lying like a pig!
He looks like death, a quite revolting sight!

Quote Analysis: The Lord, looking down at Sly asleep on the ground. To the nobleman the drunken tinker is first an animal, a "swine", and then a picture of death. He does not see a man. A moment later he has thought of a use for him. The lines show how the top of the social scale regards the bottom, and they come from the character who will spend the next scene pretending that the difference does not exist.

Quote 2

Beggars, that come unto my father's door,
Upon entreaty have a present alms;
If not, elsewhere they meet with charity...

(Katharina, Act 4, Scene 3)

Shakespeare Retold (Modern Verse)
The beggars that come to my father’s door
Are given gifts of charity when asking;
If not, they will find charity in others.

Quote Analysis: Katharina, starving at Petruchio’s house. She measures her fall by rank: beggars at her father’s door are given food, and she, a rich man’s daughter who "never knew how to entreat", is given none. Part of the taming is a loss of status. She has been taken from a great house in the city to a cold one in the country and made to ask a servant for her dinner.

Quote 3

O monstrous arrogance! Thou liest,
Thou thread, thou thimble,
Thou yard, three-quarters, half-yard, quarter, nail!
Thou flea, thou nit, thou winter-cricket thou!

(Petruchio, Act 4, Scene 3)

Shakespeare Retold (Modern Verse)
What arrogance! Well, you are lying,
You thread and thimble,
You narrow piece of cloth, small in dimensions!
You flea, you nit, you winter-cricket, you!

Quote Analysis: Petruchio to the tailor, who has dared to answer back. Each insult is drawn from the man’s trade and each is smaller than the last: a thread, a thimble, a yard, then fractions of a yard down to a "nail", and finally a flea, a nit and a cricket. A tradesman is being told his size. It is very funny, and it is a gentleman reminding a working man that he may not contradict.

Quote 4

Thy father! O villain! He is a sailmaker in Bergamo.
(Vincentio, Act 5, Scene 1)

Shakespeare Retold (Modern Verse)
Your father! Oh, villain! Your father is a sailmaker in Bergamo.

Quote Analysis: Vincentio to Tranio, who has just thanked his "good father" for his fine clothes. The answer is one fact: the servant’s father makes sails in Bergamo. It is meant to be crushing, and in Padua it is. Yet the audience has watched this sail-maker’s son outwit every gentleman in the play, and the line that puts him in his place also reminds us where his talents came from.

Key Takeaways

  • Rank as Costume: A tinker passes for a lord and a servant for a gentleman once they are given the clothes and the manner.
  • Masters and Men: Servants are beaten and insulted as a matter of course, and the play treats a master's right to do so as settled.
  • Katharina's Fall: The taming strips a rich man's daughter of the food, dress and deference that belong to her rank.
  • Order Restored: By the end the servant is a servant again, but the play has shown how thin the difference was.

Study Questions and Analysis

Why does the play begin with Christopher Sly?

Because Sly’s story is a small version of the play’s main idea, that people can be made into something else by the way they are treated. The Lord explains the experiment to his servants before they carry the tinker in.

Persuade him that he hath been lunatic;
And when he says he is, say that he dreams,
For he is nothing but a mighty lord.

(Lord, Induction, Scene 1)

Shakespeare Retold (Modern Verse)
Persuade him that he has been acting mad;
And when he says he’s mad now, say he’s dreaming,
For he is nothing but a mighty lord.

If he says he is Sly, they are to tell him he dreams; he is "nothing but a mighty lord". The method is patient contradiction by people who all say the same thing. It is how Petruchio will later deal with Katharina, and the Induction lets us see it tried first on a man, by his social superior, purely for amusement.

Karen Newman, in her "Modern Perspective" essay for the Folger edition, links the scene to the anxieties of the 1590s. It was a period, she says, when "merchants and actors, servants and apprentices" were moving into "social spheres that had been customarily closed to them", and when men "complained of upstart courtiership" and of "masterless men". A tinker, with no fixed master and no fixed home, was exactly the kind of person the authorities worried about. Putting him in a lord’s bed is a joke on those fears. Newman also places it among the play’s many changes of identity, which she thinks work "to undermine notions of an essential self or a fixed identity". William Hazlitt, in Characters of Shakespear’s Plays (1817), simply loved the character and thought that "The character of Sly and the remarks with which he accompanies the play are as good as the play itself." There is a class point in the framing too. The comedy of Padua, with its merchants and heiresses, is performed by hired players for a nobleman’s household, with a tinker in the best seat. The audience is asked to watch a story about rank from a position where rank has just been turned upside down.

Does Sly make a convincing lord?

He makes a willing one. For a few minutes he insists on his own name and trade. Then he is told about his lady, smells the perfumes and feels the bedclothes, and comes to a decision.

Upon my life, I am a lord indeed
And not a tinker nor Christophero Sly.

(Sly, Induction, Scene 2)

Shakespeare Retold (Modern Verse)
And now I swear I am a lord indeed,
And not that pot-mender, Christopher Sly.

He has switched into verse, the speech of the gentry, in the middle of the scene. His next request is for his wife, and the one after that is for "a pot o’ the smallest ale". The new lord has the old thirst.

William Hazlitt (1817) put the comedy exactly: Sly "is very slow in giving up his personal identity in his sudden advancement", and even "in the midst of splendour and luxury still calls out lustily and repeatedly" for his ale. Hazlitt enjoyed the stubbornness. Later critics have asked what it implies. One reading is conservative: breeding will out, and a tinker in silk is still a tinker. The contrast with Tranio, who passes for a gentleman without a slip, complicates that. Tranio has had years in a gentleman’s household to learn the part; Sly has had ten minutes. The difference between them looks like training. Barbara Mowat and Paul Werstine, the Folger editors, are more interested in what happens to Sly afterwards, which is nothing. Because the First Folio text "lacks a closing frame for the Sly story", he is never shown going back to his rags. In the anonymous Taming of a Shrew of 1594 he is put outside the alehouse again and wakes thinking he has dreamed. Shakespeare’s play, as we have it, leaves him a lord. Whether that is an accident of printing or a decision, it means the one transformation of rank that is never reversed belongs to the poorest man in the cast.

How does the exchange between Tranio and Lucentio affect the people around them?

It confuses those who know them and convinces everyone else. The first to see it is their boy, Biondello, who walks in on the two of them in each other’s clothes.

Where have I been! Nay, how now! Where are you? Master, has my fellow Tranio stolen your clothes? Or you stolen his? Or both? Pray, what's the news?
(Biondello, Act 1, Scene 1)

Shakespeare Retold (Modern Verse)
Where have I been! No, what is this? Where are you? Master, has my colleague Tranio stolen your clothes? Or have you stolen his? Or both? Tell me, what’s going on?

He thinks one has robbed the other. His questions are a servant’s questions: clothes are property, and a man in his master’s coat has either stolen it or been given a reason. Lucentio supplies a reason, a lie about a killing, and orders the boy to call Tranio "master" in public.

What follows is one of the play’s quiet lessons in how status works. Padua accepts Tranio without a question, because he has the hat, the cloak, a page at his heels and the right way of speaking. Karen Newman, in her "Modern Perspective" essay for the Folger edition, counts this among the exchanges by which the play unsettles fixed identities: "Lucentio and Tranio exchange identities as master and servant". Barbara Mowat and Paul Werstine note how casually the master does it, as one who "spontaneously throws off his social status as a gentleman". The casualness is itself a mark of rank. Lucentio can stop being a gentleman for a month because he knows he can start again. Tranio’s position is the reverse. For him the role is a risk, and when Vincentio arrives it nearly ruins him. Some critics take the subplot as gently radical, a demonstration that a servant can do a gentleman’s job better than the gentleman. Others stress that the scheme is the master’s, carried out at the master’s order and for the master’s benefit, so that even at his freest Tranio is doing as he is told. Both are fair. See Tranio for the full character study.

How are servants treated in the play?

Roughly, and without apology. Petruchio’s arrival at his country house is the fullest example. He comes in shouting for attendance and finds fault with every man who answers.

You peasant swain! You whoreson malt-horse drudge!
Did I not bid thee meet me in the park,
And bring along these rascal knaves with thee?

(Petruchio, Act 4, Scene 1)

Shakespeare Retold (Modern Verse)
You peasant, packhorse, drudging son of a bitch!
Did I not say to meet me in the park,
And bring these stupid rogues along with you?

"Peasant", "drudge", "rascal knaves": the vocabulary is the vocabulary of rank, and it is used to put the men at a distance. Grumio has excuses ready, about unfinished coats and unblacked shoes, and Petruchio brushes them aside. The supper is thrown about the room.

How we take this depends on how we take the whole taming. In the farce tradition servants exist to be knocked about, and nobody is meant to feel it. William Hazlitt (1817) saw only high spirits, a master acting his "assumed character to the life" and "without a particle of ill humour". But the scene has a purpose beyond noise. Petruchio is performing for Katharina, and what he performs is a master’s authority in his own house. One of the servants understands this and says that he "kills her in her own humour". Karen Newman, in her "Modern Perspective" essay for the Folger edition, connects household rule and state rule in the thinking of the time, in which "the wife’s duty to obey her husband is equated with the subject’s duty to obey the prince"; servants were the third term in that chain, owing obedience to both. Katharina has been used to giving orders to servants. Here she finds herself begging one for food, and pleading with her husband on their behalf when he strikes them. It is among the first signs of a change in her, and it comes from seeing power used on people weaker than herself. See Petruchio for the full character study.

Why do clothes matter so much in the play?

Because in Padua clothes are how rank is read. That is why Sly is given a lord’s wardrobe, why Tranio needs only a cloak, and why Vincentio is so appalled by a doublet. Petruchio makes the point by breaking the rule. He destroys the fine gown ordered for Katharina and takes her home to her father dressed plainly.

O, no, good Kate; neither art thou the worse
For this poor furniture and mean array.

(Petruchio, Act 4, Scene 3)

Shakespeare Retold (Modern Verse)
Oh, no, dear Kate; and you are none the worse
For wearing these cheap clothes and poor attire.

She is none the worse for poor clothes. He has just argued that the mind makes the body rich, and that honour shows through the meanest dress as the sun breaks through cloud. It is a fine sentiment, and it comes from a gentleman who has never had to be judged by a shabby coat unless he chose to wear one.

The scene with the tailor has drawn two kinds of comment. Natasha Korda, in Shakespeare Quarterly (1996), read it as a struggle over consumption: Katharina, a wealthy merchant’s daughter, expects to dress to her station, and Petruchio "seeks to educate her in her role as a consumer" by deciding what she may have. Karen Newman, in her "Modern Perspective" essay for the Folger edition, lists among the things denied her "the fashionable accoutrements of her social class". On this view the plain dress is a demotion, one more way of making her dependent. The other reading takes Petruchio’s sermon seriously. The play has shown again and again that fine clothes prove nothing: they make a lord of a tinker and a gentleman of a sail-maker’s son. A husband who teaches his wife to despise them might be teaching her something true. The difficulty is that he makes the point by force, and that he himself keeps the power to choose. A person who can afford to dress badly for effect is in a different position from one who has had her gown taken away. The theme of marriage and economics covers the money behind the wardrobe.

Is the social order restored at the end?

On the surface, completely. The servant is exposed, the father is recognised, and the son takes the blame as a master should.

What Tranio did, myself enforced him to;
Then pardon him, sweet father, for my sake.

(Lucentio, Act 5, Scene 1)

Shakespeare Retold (Modern Verse)
What Tranio did, he did it on my order;
So please forgive him, father, for my sake.

"Enforced" is the important word. A servant is not responsible for what his master orders, so the offence becomes Lucentio’s, and Lucentio is a gentleman in love, who can be forgiven. The rules that Tranio broke are the same rules that now protect him.

Critics differ on how much the restoration settles. One view is that the play is thoroughly conservative: it enjoys turning rank upside down for a few hours, as festivals did, and then turns it back, with the tinker, the servant and the wife each returned to their place. Another view notices how much has been shown on the way. Karen Newman, in her "Modern Perspective" essay for the Folger edition, suggests that the comedy appeals now because audiences "take pleasure" in its "representation of the instability both of conventional gender hierarchies and of human identity itself". After watching Tranio, it is hard to believe that birth explains very much. The last scene supports both readings. Tranio is at the table, joking with his betters, and makes a wry remark about being the greyhound that catches for its master. And the play’s frame is left open: Sly, who began the evening as a tinker, is never seen to become one again. Katharina’s final speech uses the language of rank for marriage, comparing a wife to a subject and a husband to a prince. Whether we believe her may depend on how seriously we have learnt to take anyone’s rank in this play. The theme of gender and patriarchy follows that question through.

James Anthony

James Anthony is an award-winning, multi-genre author from London, England. With a keen eye, sharp wit, and poetic irreverence, he retold all 154 of Shakespeare's sonnets in modern verse, published by Penguin Random House in 2018. Described by Stephen Fry as 'a dazzling success,' he continues to retell the Bard's greatest plays in his popular 'Shakespeare Retold' series. When not tackling the Bard, Anthony is an offbeat travel writer, documenting his trips in his 'Slow Road' series, earning him the moniker the English Bill Bryson. Anthony also performs globally as a solo tribute act to English political troubadour Billy Bragg.

https://www.james-anthony.com
Previous
Previous

Disguise and Deception

Next
Next

Power and Control