Gender and Patriarchy

A purple hat lies on a stone corridor, representing the theme of Gender and Patriarchy in The Taming of the Shrew.

Theme Profile – At a Glance

  • Focus: What Padua expects of a woman, and what happens to one who will not supply it. The play shows fathers and husbands deciding how women should speak, and gives its longest speech to a woman.
  • Key Characters: Katharina, Petruchio, Bianca, Baptista, Hortensio, Lucentio, the Widow, Bartholomew the Page.
  • The Core Tension: The ideal woman is silent and obedient. The woman the play is about is neither, and the two who seem to be turn out otherwise. Nobody can say for certain what the ending proves.
  • Key Manifestations: A boy coached to play an obedient wife (Induction); Katharina called a devil for answering back (A1S1); a marriage made over her refusal (A2S1); the taming (A4S1, A4S3); the speech on a wife’s duty, and two wives who will not obey (A5S2).
  • Famous Quote:
    "Such duty as the subject owes the prince
    Even such a woman oweth to her husband..."

    (Act 5, Scene 2)
  • The Outcome: Katharina preaches obedience and Bianca and the Widow refuse it. The men call the shrew tamed; the last line of the play wonders about it.

With Soft Low Tongue

Before we meet any of the women of Padua, the play shows us how a wife is made. In the Induction a lord decides to convince a drunken tinker that he is a nobleman, and for that the tinker needs a lady. The Lord sends orders to his page, a boy, on how to act the part.

Original
With soft low tongue and lowly courtesy,
And say 'What is't your honour will command,
Wherein your lady and your humble wife
May show her duty and make known her love?'

(Lord, Induction, Scene 1)

Shakespeare Retold (Modern Verse)
By speaking softly and by humbly bowing,
And say, ‘What does your honour want from me,
Whereby your lady and your humble wife
Can demonstrate her duty and her love?’

A soft voice, a low curtsy, and a question about what her lord commands. If the boy cannot cry on demand, an onion in a handkerchief will do it. The page comes on in a dress a scene later and performs exactly as told.

Original
My husband and my lord, my lord and husband;
I am your wife in all obedience.

(Page, Induction, Scene 2)

Shakespeare Retold (Modern Verse)
My husband and my lord, my lord and husband;
I am your wife, and I’m here to obey you.

It is a joke about the theatre, where every woman was played by a boy. It is also a statement of the theme. The ideal wife, the play tells us at the outset, is a set of gestures that can be taught to anyone in an afternoon. When Katharina delivers her great speech on obedience four acts later, an audience may remember that it has seen this performance once already.

From All Such Devils

The first time Katharina opens her mouth she is told she will never get a husband. Baptista has offered her to his younger daughter’s suitors in the public street, and she asks if he means to make a laughing-stock of her. Hortensio answers that there will be no mates for her until she is gentler. Her reply is the kind of thing that earned her the name of shrew.

Original
I'faith, sir, you shall never need to fear:
I wis it is not half way to her heart;
But if it were, doubt not her care should be
To comb your noddle with a three-legged stool
And paint your face and use you like a fool.

(Katharina, Act 1, Scene 1)

Shakespeare Retold (Modern Verse)
In truth, sir, you will never need to fear,
For I have no intention to be married;
But even if I were, don’t doubt that I
Would make your head bleed with a wooden stool
And scratch your face and treat you like a fool.

She has no wish to marry him; but if she did, she would comb his head with a three-legged stool. It is a threat, and a good joke, and the men treat it as proof of a disorder. One calls her a devil. Another says she should be carted, the punishment for a scold. Meanwhile her sister stands silent, and a young stranger falls in love with the silence. The scene lays out the rule that governs the play: a woman is judged by how little she says. The theme of marriage and economics follows from it, because the quiet daughter is the one with a market value.

Household Kates

Petruchio states what he means to do in the language of his own house. In the middle of their first quarrel he tells Katharina what he was born for.

Original
For I am he am born to tame you Kate,
And bring you from a wild Kate to a Kate
Conformable as other household Kates.

(Petruchio, Act 2, Scene 1)

Shakespeare Retold (Modern Verse)
For I’m the man who’s born to tame you Kate,
Converting you from wild Kate to a calm Kate,
Compliant as all other household Kates.

A "wild Kate" is to become a "household" one, with a pun on "cat": a creature brought indoors and made "conformable", fitting the shape required. He does not say she is wicked. He says she is not yet domesticated. The marriage goes ahead over her loud refusal, and by the wedding day she has understood how the rules work.

Original
I see a woman may be made a fool,
If she had not a spirit to resist.

(Katharina, Act 3, Scene 2)

Shakespeare Retold (Modern Verse)
I see a woman will be made a fool
If she’s not strong enough to take a stand.

It is one of the most direct statements about a woman’s position in the play, and she says it in front of the wedding guests. A woman without the spirit to resist will be made a fool. She has the spirit, and resists, and is carried out of the room.

So Simple

The last scene reverses every expectation. The wives are sent for, and the two mild ones decline to come. Katharina arrives at once, fetches the others, and is asked by her husband to tell these "headstrong women" what they owe. Partway through her answer she speaks for her sex.

Original
I am ashamed that women are so simple
To offer war where they should kneel for peace;
Or seek for rule, supremacy and sway,
When they are bound to serve, love and obey.

(Katharina, Act 5, Scene 2)

Shakespeare Retold (Modern Verse)
I am ashamed that women are so simple
To want to fight when they should strive for peace;
Or strive for leadership and influence,
When it’s their role to serve, love and obey.

War and peace, rule and service: she uses the language of government for a marriage, and comes down on the side of the governor. The words are orthodox for 1590. The difficulty is who is saying them, and to whom, and how. A woman who was told all her life to be quiet is holding forty-four lines of uninterrupted verse while the men listen. She is obeying an order to speak. Whether that is the taming complete, or the best trick in the play, is left for the actor and the audience to settle.

"No man with any decency of feeling can sit it out in the company of a woman without being extremely ashamed of the lord-of-creation moral implied in the wager and the speech put into the woman’s own mouth."

— George Bernard Shaw, The Saturday Review, 1897

Key Quotes on Gender and Patriarchy

Quote 1

From all such devils, good Lord deliver us!
(Hortensio, Act 1, Scene 1)

Shakespeare Retold (Modern Verse)
Dear Lord, protect me from all devils like her!

Quote Analysis: Hortensio, a gentleman, of a lady standing in front of him. The line parodies the Litany, the church prayer that asks the Lord to deliver us from evil. Katharina has done nothing at this point except object to being offered round. The word "devil" is used of her again and again in the first two acts, and always by men she has contradicted.

Quote 2

Now, Kate, I am a husband for your turn;
For, by this light, whereby I see thy beauty,
Thy beauty, that doth make me like thee well,
Thou must be married to no man but me...

(Petruchio, Act 2, Scene 1)

Shakespeare Retold (Modern Verse)
Now, Kate, I am a decent husband for you;
For, in this light where I can see your beauty,
Your beauty that does make me love you so much,
You have to marry no one else but me...

Quote Analysis: Petruchio closing the wooing. The first line means that he is the husband to suit her; the last leaves her no say in it. Between them is a compliment, and he seems to mean it: her beauty makes him like her well. The mixture is typical of him. He admires her and overrules her in the same breath, and treats the second as a way of showing the first.

Quote 3

Why are our bodies soft and weak and smooth,
Unapt to toil and trouble in the world,
But that our soft conditions and our hearts
Should well agree with our external parts?

(Katharina, Act 5, Scene 2)

Shakespeare Retold (Modern Verse)
Why are our bodies weak, with smooth and soft skin,
Unfit to work and fight within our world,
If not so that our hearts and gentle traits
Align with what our body indicates?

Quote Analysis: Katharina near the end of her speech. The argument is from nature: women’s bodies are soft and weak, so their tempers should be soft as well. It was a commonplace of the period. On Shakespeare’s stage the lines were spoken by a boy actor, whose body was not what the words describe, and some critics think the play expects us to notice.

Quote 4

Your husband, being troubled with a shrew,
Measures my husband's sorrow by his woe...

(Widow, Act 5, Scene 2)

Shakespeare Retold (Modern Verse)
Your husband, who has trouble with a shrew,
Compares his troubles to my husband’s sorrow.

Quote Analysis: The Widow to Katharina at the feast. She means that Petruchio, having a shrew for a wife, assumes every husband is as unhappy as he is. The word "shrew" is now being thrown by one woman at another, in public, at a wedding. Minutes later the Widow will refuse to come when her own husband calls, and the label will change hands.

Key Takeaways

  • The Ideal: Padua wants women silent, mild and obedient, and rewards Bianca for seeming to be all three.
  • The Label: 'Shrew' and 'devil' are what the men call a woman who answers back; Katharina's first offence is to speak.
  • The Performance: The Induction shows a boy being taught to play an obedient wife, which frames everything that follows.
  • The Ending: Katharina preaches submission in the longest speech of the play while the two 'ideal' wives disobey.

Study Questions and Analysis

What did "shrew" mean in Shakespeare’s time?

A scolding, bad-tempered woman, one who would not hold her tongue or do as she was told. It was a term of abuse and could be a legal matter. The first verdict on Katharina in the play comes from a stranger who has watched her for a minute.

That wench is stark mad or wonderful froward.
(Tranio, Act 1, Scene 1)

Shakespeare Retold (Modern Verse)
That wench is either stubborn or she’s mad.

"Froward" means wilful, hard to manage. Tranio has seen a woman object to her father and threaten a suitor, and the choice he offers is that she is either mad or perverse. That she might be justified does not occur to him.

The label had force behind it. Karen Newman, in her "Modern Perspective" essay for the Folger edition, describes how Elizabethan communities dealt with women judged unruly: "the ducking stool", "carting", and rough processions in which a scold was paraded through the town to the banging of pots and pans. She adds that "Although men were occasionally charged with scolding, shrewishness was a predominately female offense." The play brushes against this at once, when Gremio answers Baptista’s invitation to court Katharina with "To cart her rather". Newman’s argument is that such punishments grew out of a wider fear of disorder, and that "Anxiety about changing social relations prompted the labeling of old behaviors in new ways that made criminals of women whose actions threatened patriarchal authority." Lynda Boose, in Shakespeare Quarterly (1991), went into the grimmer history of the scold’s bridle, an iron muzzle used to silence women, and argued that the comedy cannot be separated from the practices behind it. Against that, the folk tales Shakespeare drew on are far more brutal than his play, and he gives his shrew wit, a grievance and the best lines. The word is the title’s, and the play makes us ask who is using it. See Katharina for the full character study.

Why are the men so drawn to Bianca’s silence?

Because silence is what they have been taught to admire. The clearest case is Lucentio, who watches both sisters and is won by the one who says least. When she finally speaks four meek lines to her father, he is enraptured.

Hark, Tranio! Thou may'st hear Minerva speak.
(Lucentio, Act 1, Scene 1)

Shakespeare Retold (Modern Verse)
Listen! Minerva speaks, goddess of wisdom.

Minerva is the goddess of wisdom. Bianca has said that she will obey and keep to her books. To the listening young man this is wisdom itself, because it is exactly what a woman is supposed to say.

Karen Newman, in her "Modern Perspective" essay for the Folger edition, opens her essay with the standard of the time, "the tripartite ideal of women’s chastity, silence, and obedience", which she says "was proclaimed far and wide in early modern England" in sermons, conduct books and plays. The suitors, she notes, admire Bianca "for her silence, mildness, and sobriety". Barbara Mowat and Paul Werstine, the Folger editors, describe Lucentio’s feeling as "idealized love of an apparently ideal woman". The word "apparently" matters, since the ideal turns out to be something Bianca can put on. In the lesson scene she tells two men she will learn as she pleases; she marries without her father’s leave; and at the feast she will not come when called. Some critics read this as hypocrisy exposed. Others think it shows what the ideal produces. If a woman is rewarded only for seeming quiet, she will learn to seem quiet and keep her will for when it is safe. On that view Bianca and Katharina are two responses to the same pressure, one concealed and one open, and Padua punishes the honest one. The theme of illusion vs reality takes this further. See Bianca for the full character study.

Does Katharina ever defy the men openly?

Constantly at first, and for the last time at her wedding. Petruchio announces that they must leave before the feast. Katharina says she will not go, and when her father tries to calm things she silences him.

Father, be quiet; he shall stay my leisure.
(Katharina, Act 3, Scene 2)

Shakespeare Retold (Modern Verse)
Father, be quiet; he’ll stay until I’m ready.

"He shall stay my leisure": the bridegroom will wait until she is ready. It is a daughter giving orders to her father and a wife setting terms to her husband in one line. She then invites the company in to dinner as if the house were hers. Within a minute Petruchio has claimed her as his property and removed her.

This is the turning point for the theme. Up to here Katharina has fought in the open and lost each time: she said no to the match and was betrothed, she was left waiting at the church, and now she is taken from her own wedding. After it she never again gives a direct order to a man. Coppélia Kahn, in an essay of 1975, argued that the play shows male authority as something that has to be staged and insisted on, and that Petruchio’s victory is one of appearances: he "has gained her outward compliance in the form of a public display, while her spirit remains mischievously free". Emily Detmer, in Shakespeare Quarterly (1997), took the darker view that what replaces open defiance is the behaviour of someone who has learnt that defiance costs too much. The text gives each of them something. Katharina’s last flash of open anger, over a cap in A4S3, is a declaration that she will speak her mind or her heart will break. She is ignored. What she does next, on the road and at the feast, is done by other means. The theme of power and control traces the same change.

Is The Taming of the Shrew a sexist play?

It is a play about sexism, written inside a society that took male authority for granted, and readers have never agreed on which side it is on. Petruchio himself raises the question. Having explained how he will starve his wife into obedience, he turns to the audience.

He that knows better how to tame a shrew,
Now let him speak: 'tis charity to show.

(Petruchio, Act 4, Scene 1)

Shakespeare Retold (Modern Verse)
If there’s a better way to tame a shrew,
Speak up; it is the kindest thing to do.

It is an invitation to answer back. Shakespeare could have let the taming pass without comment. He has the tamer stop and ask whether anyone has a better idea.

The case against the play is simple and strong. A woman is married against her will, deprived of food and sleep, and ends by telling other women to put their hands under their husbands’ feet. George Bernard Shaw, in the Saturday Review in 1897, called the last scene "altogether disgusting to modern sensibility". The case for it rests on tone and structure. The story is framed as an entertainment for a drunken tinker; the taming is done by a man performing an obvious act; and the meek women turn out worse wives than the shrew. Barbara Mowat and Paul Werstine, in the Folger edition, suggest that with a closing frame we might take the inner play "as a kind of parody on marriage customs and male fantasies about how women should and should not behave". There is also early evidence that the play made people uneasy. About 1611 John Fletcher wrote a sequel, The Woman’s Prize, or The Tamer Tamed, in which Petruchio’s second wife tames him. Harold Goddard, in The Meaning of Shakespeare (1951), thought it impossible that Shakespeare meant the ending literally, since it would commit him to "the wholly un-Shakespearean doctrine of male superiority". That is an argument from faith in the author, and not everyone shares it. The safest statement is that the play stages the patriarchal case at full strength and surrounds it with reasons to doubt.

How should we read Katharina’s final speech?

With the whole of it in view, including its last and most extreme image. Having argued that wives owe obedience as subjects owe it to a prince, Katharina tells the other women what to do.

Then vail your stomachs, for it is no boot,
And place your hands below your husband's foot...

(Katharina, Act 5, Scene 2)

Shakespeare Retold (Modern Verse)
So wind your necks in, for it does no good,
And be submissive, doing what you should...

To "vail your stomachs" is to lower your pride; "it is no boot" means it is no use. Placing a hand beneath a husband’s foot was an old gesture of submission. She offers to do it. Petruchio does not ask her to, and answers with a kiss.

Karen Newman, in her "Modern Perspective" essay for the Folger edition, begins from the fact that "No lines in the play have been more variously interpreted than this final speech". Some take it as proof of the taming; others, she says, "argue that it must be understood ironically as pretense, a strategy for living peaceably in patriarchal culture". Her own point is about the act of speaking. At the moment the play states most forcefully that women should be silent and submissive, a woman is "speaking forcefully and in public the longest speech in the play", and so "Kate’s speaking as she does contradicts the very sentiments she affirms." Germaine Greer, in The Female Eunuch (1970), defended the speech as sincere and admirable, on the ground that "The submission of a woman like Kate is genuine and exciting because she has something to lay down, her virgin pride and individuality". Robert Heilman (1966) thought both the outrage and the irony overdone, since the scene belongs to "the realm of farce". In the theatre the speech has been delivered broken, mocking, loving and exhausted, and each version has persuaded audiences. The text will not choose for us. It gives Katharina eloquence and control at the instant she renounces both.

Why do Bianca and the Widow refuse to obey?

Because nobody has tamed them, and they see no reason to perform. When Petruchio tells Katharina to lecture the other wives, the Widow objects at once.

WIDOW: Come, come, you're mocking: we will have no telling.
PETRUCHIO: Come on, I say; and first begin with her.
WIDOW: She shall not.
PETRUCHIO: I say she shall: and first begin with her.

(Act 5, Scene 2)

Shakespeare Retold (Modern Verse)
WIDOW: You must be joking; we will not be told.
PETRUCHIO: I say you tell them; and you start with her.
WIDOW: She won’t tell me.
PETRUCHIO: I say she will: and first begin with her.

"She shall not." It is a flat refusal, in company, to a man. A few lines earlier she sent word to her husband that he could come to her. Bianca has told hers that he was a fool to bet on her duty. The two women the play presented as agreeable have become the difficult ones.

Karen Newman, in her "Modern Perspective" essay for the Folger edition, sums up the pattern: "if in the end one shrew is tamed, two more reveal themselves: Bianca and the widow refuse to do their husbands’ bidding at the very moment Kate has ostensibly learned to obey." She describes them as women "who begin by conforming to oppressive codes of womanly duty" and then "reveal their independence". How to value this is disputed. In the older reading the two are warnings, and their husbands are being punished for choosing wives by appearances. In a modern reading they are simply behaving like people: they will not come running for a bet. There is a harder question underneath. If Bianca and the Widow are free to refuse, why is Katharina not? One answer is that she has been broken and they have not. Another is that she is the only one of the three who is in partnership with her husband, and that her obedience is a move in a game the two of them are winning. The play closes on a remark from Lucentio that leaves it open: it is a wonder she "will be tamed so". The theme of education and transformation asks the same thing in a different form, namely what, if anything, Katharina has been taught.

James Anthony

James Anthony is an award-winning, multi-genre author from London, England. With a keen eye, sharp wit, and poetic irreverence, he retold all 154 of Shakespeare's sonnets in modern verse, published by Penguin Random House in 2018. Described by Stephen Fry as 'a dazzling success,' he continues to retell the Bard's greatest plays in his popular 'Shakespeare Retold' series. When not tackling the Bard, Anthony is an offbeat travel writer, documenting his trips in his 'Slow Road' series, earning him the moniker the English Bill Bryson. Anthony also performs globally as a solo tribute act to English political troubadour Billy Bragg.

https://www.james-anthony.com
Previous
Previous

Marriage and Economics

Next
Next

Disguise and Deception