Theme Profile – At a Glance
- Focus: How people in the play are taught, trained and changed. Padua is a university town full of tutors, and its most thorough course of instruction is given by a husband to his wife.
- Key Characters: Lucentio, Tranio, Bianca, Hortensio, Petruchio, Katharina, Baptista, Christopher Sly.
- The Core Tension: The play calls the taming a school and compares it to training a hawk. It asks whether Katharina is educated or broken, and whether anyone else learns anything at all.
- Key Manifestations: A tinker taught he is a lord (Induction); a student abandons his books for love (A1S1); two false tutors and a wilful pupil (A3S1); the falcon soliloquy (A4S1); the "taming-school" (A4S2); a wife who lectures other wives (A5S2).
- Famous Quote:
"No profit grows where is no pleasure ta'en:
In brief, sir, study what you most affect."
(Act 1, Scene 1) - The Outcome: Katharina ends the play as the teacher, instructing the other wives. The men who studied her husband’s methods have learnt nothing they can use.
A Course of Learning
The story set in Padua begins with a young man arriving to study. Lucentio has come to a famous university town with his father’s blessing, and he has his subjects chosen.
Original
And therefore, Tranio, for the time I study,
Virtue and that part of philosophy
Will I apply that treats of happiness
By virtue specially to be achieved.
(Lucentio, Act 1, Scene 1)
Shakespeare Retold (Modern Verse)
And therefore, Tranio, right now I’ll study
The art of being kind, and all I learn
I will apply to help myself be happy
Through kindness which will help me reach my goals.
Virtue, and the branch of philosophy that deals with happiness. It is a worthy programme, and it lasts about forty lines. His servant Tranio suggests that study should be pleasant or it will do no good, and a moment later a pretty girl walks past and the philosophy is forgotten. The play is fond of this joke. Lucentio does spend his time in Padua in a schoolroom, but as a teacher under a false name, and what he teaches is himself. Formal learning in the play is nearly always a cover for something else. The theme of disguise and deception supplies the gowns.
Rudiments of Art
Baptista wants his daughters educated, and hires masters in music and languages. Both are suitors in costume, and the lesson that follows is a comedy of men trying to instruct a woman who has her own ideas. Hortensio, as the music master, begins in the proper way.
Original
Madam, before you touch the instrument,
To learn the order of my fingering,
I must begin with rudiments of art...
(Hortensio, Act 3, Scene 1)
Shakespeare Retold (Modern Verse)
Madam, before you touch the instrument,
So you can see how I deploy my fingers,
I have to start with music fundamentals...
She must learn the fingering before she touches the lute, and the "rudiments" before anything else. He means to slip a declaration of love into the scale. Bianca has just told both tutors that she will learn her lessons as she pleases, and she dismisses his new method in two lines. With the Latin master she gets on better. A scene later the two of them are heard discussing their reading.
Original
LUCENTIO: Now, mistress, profit you in what you read?
BIANCA: What, master, read you? First resolve me that.
LUCENTIO: I read that I profess, the Art to Love.
BIANCA: And may you prove, sir, master of your art!
(Act 4, Scene 2)
Shakespeare Retold (Modern Verse)
LUCENTIO: Now, lady, are you learning from your reading?
BIANCA: What are you reading, sir? First tell me that.
LUCENTIO: I’m reading what I teach, the Art of Love.
BIANCA: And, sir, I hope you’ll master what you’re reading!
The book is Ovid’s Art of Love, a manual of seduction, and "master of your art" is a pun on the university degree. This is the one piece of teaching in the subplot that succeeds, and the pupil is plainly directing it. Bianca learns what she chooses to learn, from the teacher she has chosen. Her sister’s schooling will be of a different kind.
To Man My Haggard
Petruchio describes his treatment of Katharina as a course of training, and he takes his terms from falconry. Alone on stage, he explains.
Original
Another way I have to man my haggard,
To make her come and know her keeper's call,
That is, to watch her, as we watch these kites
That bate and beat and will not be obedient.
(Petruchio, Act 4, Scene 1)
Shakespeare Retold (Modern Verse)
Another way I have to tame my falcon,
To make her understand who is the boss,
Is stopping her from sleeping, as we do kites
That flap their wings and won’t do as we tell them.
A "haggard" is a hawk caught wild as an adult, the hardest kind to tame. To "man" it is to make it used to its keeper. The method was to "watch" the bird, to keep it awake night after night until exhaustion made it give in; "bate and beat" describes a hawk flapping against the leash. Petruchio has already said that his falcon is hungry and must not be fed until she comes to the lure. Now he adds sleep. He intends to keep his wife awake as a falconer keeps a kite awake, and he will stay up to do it. The image is carefully chosen. A trained hawk is not a broken animal. It is valued for its spirit, and it flies free and returns. But it is also a wild creature brought to obey by hunger. The theme of power and control looks at the same scenes for what they are as well as for what they are called.
New-Built Virtue
The result of the course is shown in public. At the wedding feast Katharina comes when her husband calls, and he is not content with one demonstration.
Original
Nay, I will win my wager better yet
And show more sign of her obedience,
Her new-built virtue and obedience.
(Petruchio, Act 5, Scene 2)
Shakespeare Retold (Modern Verse)
I’ll win this bet more comprehensively
And show you more of her obedience,
Her new-learnt merits and obedience.
"New-built" is the phrase to notice. Her virtue is a recent piece of construction, and he is showing it off like a man with a new house. She is then asked to teach. The pupil of the taming-school is set to instruct the two wives who have refused to come, and gives the longest speech in the play on what women owe their husbands. Whether she has been transformed, or has learnt how to give the right answers, is something the speech does not settle. What is certain is that she, alone of the three wives, now knows what is being asked and how to supply it. The theme of gender and patriarchy takes up what the lesson contains.
"In both popular and elite materials on marriage and education, taming or educating a wife is likened to the training or domestication of animals—unbroken horses, intractable cats, untamed hawks, even wild beasts."
— Karen Newman, A Modern Perspective: The Taming of the Shrew, Folger Shakespeare Library
Key Quotes on Education and Transformation
Quote 1
Here let us breathe and haply institute
A course of learning and ingenious studies.
(Lucentio, Act 1, Scene 1)
Shakespeare Retold (Modern Verse)
Let’s stop here and, perhaps, we can begin
A course of intellectual education.
Quote Analysis: Lucentio on arriving in Padua. "Institute" means begin, and "ingenious" studies are those fit for a gentleman, the liberal arts. It is the voice of a serious young man with a plan. The play proper opens with these lines so that everything after them can be measured against the plan. Within the scene he has thrown it over for a face in the street.
In her chamber, making a sermon of continency to her;
And rails, and swears, and rates, that she, poor soul,
Knows not which way to stand, to look, to speak,
And sits as one new-risen from a dream.
(Curtis, Act 4, Scene 1)
Shakespeare Retold (Modern Verse)
Her bedroom, preaching sexual self-control;
He shouts and swears and rants so much, the poor soul
Does not know where to stand, to look, or speak,
And sits like one just woken from a dream.
Quote Analysis: The servant Curtis reports what is happening in the bridal chamber. Petruchio is lecturing his wife on "continency", self-restraint, the very quality she is said to lack, while he himself rails and swears. He is teaching by exaggerated bad example. The effect on the pupil is in the last two lines: she does not know which way to stand or look, and sits like someone just woken from a dream. It is a picture of a person whose bearings have been taken away.
Well, forward, forward! Thus the bowl should run,
And not unluckily against the bias.
(Petruchio, Act 4, Scene 5)
Shakespeare Retold (Modern Verse)
Well, let’s continue! This is how things should be,
And not unfortunately knocked off course.
Quote Analysis: Petruchio on the road, when Katharina has agreed to call the sun whatever he likes. The image is from the game of bowls. A bowl is weighted on one side, its "bias", so that it runs in a curve; played well, it follows its natural course to the mark. He is saying that she is now running true. The metaphor is kinder than the falcon. It suggests that her agreeing with him is her proper bent, which is a large thing for him to assume.
Well, Petruchio, this has put me in heart.
Have to my widow! And if she be froward,
Then hast thou taught Hortensio to be untoward.
(Hortensio, Act 4, Scene 5)
Shakespeare Retold (Modern Verse)
Well, Petruchio, I feel encouraged.
I’ll see my widow! And if she’s a shrew,
Then, as you’ve taught me, I’ll be stubborn too.
Quote Analysis: Hortensio, who has been watching the taming as a student. He is off to marry a widow, and if she proves "froward", wilful, he now knows what to do. He treats what he has seen as a technique that can be copied. The last scene shows how wrong he is. His widow defies him at the first test, and the one graduate of Petruchio’s school turns out to have learnt only the confidence.
Key Takeaways
- False Schoolmasters: The official lessons in the play are covers for courtship, and the pupil, Bianca, learns only what she chooses.
- The Falcon: Petruchio describes taming his wife as training a wild hawk, by hunger and lack of sleep.
- The Taming-School: Others treat his method as a set of tricks to be learnt, and fail when they try them.
- Pupil Turned Teacher: Katharina ends by instructing the other wives, and the play leaves open what she has really learnt.
Study Questions and Analysis
Why is there so much teaching in the play?
Because the play is interested in how people are shaped, and it sets its story in a town known for its university. Nearly every character is a teacher or a pupil at some point. Baptista, a conscientious father, engages tutors for his daughters and sends them straight to work.
Take you the lute, and you the set of books;
You shall go see your pupils presently.
(Baptista, Act 2, Scene 1)
Shakespeare Retold (Modern Verse)
And take the lute, and you take all the books;
And soon you’ll go and meet up with your pupils.
A lute for one and a set of books for the other. He believes he is providing for his daughters’ improvement. In fact he has just let two suitors into the house, and the first lesson ends with the lute broken over the music master’s head.
William Hazlitt, in Characters of Shakespear’s Plays (1817), found this side of the play overdone and complained that "there is a little too much about music-masters and masters of philosophy". Later critics have thought the schoolroom scenes essential, because they set up a contrast. Karen Newman, in her "Modern Perspective" essay for the Folger edition, places the taming in a tradition of writing about how wives should be formed. Humanist authors of the period, she explains, "recommend persuasion, not brutality, as the means of inculcating wifely obedience", and wrote of marriage and education together. In the same tradition, "taming or educating a wife is likened to the training or domestication of animals". The play gives us both kinds of schooling side by side. In Baptista’s house there is book-learning, which is a sham, with a pupil who does as she likes. In Petruchio’s house there is training in the animal sense, which is in earnest, with a pupil who has no choice. The joke on Lucentio is that he came to Padua for philosophy and is last seen losing a bet about whether his wife will come when called. The serious question is which kind of education the play believes in. See Lucentio for the full character study.
What is the "taming-school"?
It is Tranio’s name for Petruchio’s household, and it treats the taming as a subject that can be taught. Hortensio has given up Bianca and gone to learn how to manage the widow he means to marry. Tranio explains where he is.
TRANIO: Faith, he is gone unto the taming-school.
BIANCA: The taming-school! What, is there such a place?
TRANIO: Ay, mistress, and Petruchio is the master;
That teacheth tricks eleven and twenty long,
To tame a shrew and charm her chattering tongue.
(Act 4, Scene 2)
Shakespeare Retold (Modern Verse)
TRANIO: He did, and he has gone to taming-school.
BIANCA: To taming-school! Well, is there such a place?
TRANIO: Yes, lady, and Petruchio is the teacher;
He teaches tricks, like counting in a card game,
To tame a shrew and silence her sharp tongue.
Bianca is amused that there should be such a place. Tranio assures her there is, with Petruchio as master and a curriculum of "tricks eleven and twenty long". The tone is light. It is gossip between a servant and a young woman who is busy escaping her own father’s control.
The phrase has shaped how the play is read. If the taming is a school, then Katharina is a student and Petruchio a teacher, and the question becomes what is on the syllabus. For readers who admire him, such as William Hazlitt (1817), he is giving a lesson all husbands might profit from: "a character which most husbands ought to study". For Germaine Greer, in The Female Eunuch (1970), the lesson is real and two-sided, a hard apprenticeship in which both learn to respect the other. For critics such as Emily Detmer, in Shakespeare Quarterly (1997), "school" is a polite word for something closer to breaking a prisoner. The play itself undercuts the idea that the method can be taught. Hortensio attends, watches a hungry woman being refused her dinner, declares himself encouraged, and goes home to a wife who ignores him. Whatever happens between Petruchio and Katharina, it is not a set of tricks. It depends on those two people, and perhaps on something in her that the widow and Bianca do not share. See Hortensio for the full character study.
Why does Petruchio compare Katharina to a falcon?
Because falconry gave him a ready language for taming something wild without destroying it. The comparison opens his soliloquy.
My falcon now is sharp and passing empty;
And till she stoop she must not be full-gorged,
For then she never looks upon her lure.
(Petruchio, Act 4, Scene 1)
Shakespeare Retold (Modern Verse)
My falcon now is hungry and unfed,
And won’t be fed until she falls in line,
For otherwise she’ll never take the bait.
"Sharp" means hungry; to "stoop" is to fly down to the lure, the bait a falconer swings to call the bird back. A hawk that has eaten its fill has no reason to return. So she must not be "full-gorged" until she comes when called. He is describing, exactly, what he is doing to his wife.
Karen Newman, in her "Modern Perspective" essay for the Folger edition, notes how deliberate the borrowing is: "Shakespeare has Petruchio compare taming Kate to training a falcon, and he peppers Petruchio’s speech with the technical language of hawk taming." She sets it in a long tradition in which a wife is compared to a horse, a cat or a hawk, and comments that "Implied in this comparison is the view that women are themselves unmanageable creatures whom only rigorous training and violence, or the continued threat of violence, can render submissive." That is the harsh reading. A softer one has often been offered by those who know the sport. Hawking was a gentleman’s passion; the falconer shared the bird’s sleepless nights, and the finished hawk was a partner, flown free and trusted to come back. On that view the image honours Katharina. Germaine Greer (1970) took it so, and counted her fortunate in a husband who wanted "a wife worth keeping". The difficulty is that a hawk has no say in the matter, and no idea that there is a matter. Katharina knows precisely what is being done to her, and says so: he does it all, she complains, "under name of perfect love". The play gives us the trainer’s account and the trained creature’s account, which a real falcon could never supply. See Petruchio for the full character study.
What does Katharina actually learn?
The play shows a change in what she does and leaves us to work out what lies behind it. The change is clearest in a small moment in A5S1. Petruchio asks for a kiss in the public street, she hesitates, and he makes as if to turn for home.
Nay, I will give thee a kiss: now pray thee, love, stay.
(Katharina, Act 5, Scene 1)
Shakespeare Retold (Modern Verse)
No, I will give you a kiss: now, please, my love, stay.
"Love" is a new word from her. She gives the kiss and asks him to stay. Nobody is watching whom they need to impress, and no bet is riding on it. If we want evidence that something real has happened between them, this is the place to look.
There are three main accounts of her education. The first is that she learns obedience, which is what the title says. The second, argued by Marianne Novy in 1979, is that she learns to play: the turning point is the scene of the sun and the moon, where she discovers that agreeing with Petruchio’s absurdities can be a shared game, and from then on her obedience is a kind of performance she enjoys. Karen Newman, in her "Modern Perspective" essay for the Folger edition, describes the pair in similar terms, as a couple in which "Petruchio plays at antic ruffian and Kate at submissive wife". The third is that she learns to survive. On this reading a hungry and exhausted person finds out what she must say to be allowed to eat, sleep and see her family, and says it. Each account can point to the text. Her wit returns on the road, which suits the second. Her last speech is long and fluent, which suits the first or the second. And she is told plainly in A4S5 that the journey will not continue until she agrees, which suits the third. It is possible that all three are true together, and that what she learns is how to get what she wants in a world where she cannot simply demand it. See Katharina for the full character study.
Is Christopher Sly’s change a kind of education too?
It is a parody of one. In the Induction a tinker is taught to be a lord by the simple method of telling him that he is, over and over, until he agrees.
Thou art a lord, and nothing but a lord:
Thou hast a lady far more beautiful
Than any woman in this waning age.
(Lord, Induction, Scene 2)
Shakespeare Retold (Modern Verse)
You are a lord, you’re certainly a lord:
You have a wife who’s far more beautiful
Than any woman in these fading days.
He is a lord, with a lady more beautiful than any woman living. Servants offer music, hawks, hounds and pictures. Sly resists for a while, citing his trade and his debts, and then accepts the new account of himself and asks to see his wife.
The scene works as a preview. Sly is transformed by exactly the technique Petruchio will use: a world is arranged around him in which everyone insists on the same false thing, and the easiest course is to believe it. Karen Newman, in her "Modern Perspective" essay for the Folger edition, lists the two together among the play’s changes of identity: "Sly is persuaded he is a lord instead of a tinker", and Katharina "is transformed after enduring the irrational world of Petruchio’s country house", where she is denied food and sleep until, in the play’s words, she sits "as one new-risen from a dream". The dream image is used of both. William Hazlitt (1817) noticed that Sly’s transformation does not go very deep, since he "is very slow in giving up his personal identity" and still calls for small ale. That may be the Induction’s hint about Katharina. A person can be made to answer to a new name and still be the same person underneath. Barbara Mowat and Paul Werstine, the Folger editors, observe that if the frame had been closed, with Sly waking to find himself a tinker again, we might take the inner play "as a kind of parody" of ideas about how women should behave. The frame stays open, and so does the question of how lasting any of these lessons are.
Is any of the transformation in the play real?
The characters themselves are not sure. When Petruchio and Katharina greet old Vincentio on the road as a young girl, and then apologise, he asks them straight out.
But is it true? Or else is it your pleasure,
Like pleasant travellers, to break a jest
Upon the company you overtake?
(Vincentio, Act 4, Scene 5)
Shakespeare Retold (Modern Verse)
But is it really true? Or are you joking,
The way that cheerful travellers play jokes
On people that you pass along the way?
Is it true, or is it a joke played by merry travellers? He is asking about the news that his son has married, but the question reaches further. He has just watched two people agree that an old man is a maiden and then that he is an old man again. He cannot tell what they mean.
Critics have answered Vincentio’s question in both ways. Those who think the changes real point to how much is different by the end: a shrew who speaks of love and duty, a student who has become a husband, a suitor who has given up beauty for a widow. Those who doubt it point to how quickly everything was done and how much of it was costume. Lucentio stops being Cambio in a line. Tranio goes back to being a servant. Bianca turns out never to have been the mild girl she seemed. The only change that the play insists on is Katharina’s, and it is reported by other people: her father says she is "changed, as she had never been". Coppélia Kahn, in an essay of 1975, thought the Induction was there to warn us off taking it at face value, since Sly’s promotion is "only temporary and skin-deep" and "suggests that Kate’s switch from independence may also be deceptive". Robert Heilman had argued in 1966 that farce does not deal in inner change at all, so that asking whether Katharina is really transformed is asking the wrong kind of question. The play ends on a line that keeps the matter open. It is a wonder, says Lucentio, that she "will be tamed so". The theme of illusion vs reality begins where this one stops.