Power and Control

A hawk lands on a washing line, representing the theme of power and control in The Taming of the Shrew.

Theme Profile – At a Glance

  • Focus: How one person gets another to do, say and finally see what he wants. The play follows a contest of wills between a husband and a wife, fought with food, sleep and words.
  • Key Characters: Petruchio, Katharina, Baptista, Hortensio, Grumio and the servants, the Lord and Christopher Sly.
  • The Core Tension: Petruchio never strikes Katharina, and never lets her win. The play asks whether control gained by kindness and contradiction is gentler than force, or only harder to resist.
  • Key Manifestations: A lord toys with a beggar (Induction); a marriage declared over the bride’s refusal (A2S1); the bride removed from her wedding (A3S2); food and sleep withheld (A4S1, A4S3); the sun renamed (A4S5); a wife summoned for a bet (A5S2).
  • Famous Quote:
    "It shall be what o'clock I say it is."
    (Act 4, Scene 3)
  • The Outcome: Katharina says what her husband says, comes when he calls and wins him his wager. Whether she has lost the contest or changed its terms is left open.

Will You, Nill You

The contest between Petruchio and Katharina begins as a fair fight. In their first scene she matches him insult for insult and pun for pun, and when he goes too far she strikes him. Words are her ground, and she is winning on it. So he changes the ground.

Original
Marry, so I mean, sweet Katharina, in thy bed:
And therefore, setting all this chat aside,
Thus in plain terms: your father hath consented
That you shall be my wife; your dowry 'greed on;
And, Will you, nill you, I will marry you.

(Petruchio, Act 2, Scene 1)

Shakespeare Retold (Modern Verse)
Indeed, I mean to stay warm in your bed:
But let’s put all this chat aside for now,
And plainly talk: your father has agreed
That you will be my wife; we’ve signed your dowry;
And you don’t have a choice: I’ll marry you.

"Setting all this chat aside": the wit-combat is over because he says it is. Her father has consented, the dowry is agreed, and "will you, nill you", whether she likes it or not, he will marry her. This is the first move in his method, and it is the one that everything else depends on. Katharina can out-talk anyone in Padua. Petruchio’s answer is that talk does not decide anything. The men who hold the property decide, and he is one of them. The theme of marriage and economics supplies the contract that gives him the right.

There Lies Your Way

Katharina makes her stand at the wedding. The ceremony is over, the feast is ready, and her new husband announces that they are leaving at once. She asks him to stay, then entreats him, and then stops asking.

Original
Do what thou canst, I will not go to-day;
No, nor to-morrow, not till I please myself.
The door is open, sir; there lies your way...

(Katharina, Act 3, Scene 2)

Shakespeare Retold (Modern Verse)
Do what you like, I will not leave today;
And not tomorrow; I’ll leave when I want to.
The door is open, sir; that is the way out...

It is her clearest act of defiance in the play: she will go when she pleases, and he may leave without her. She tells the guests to go in to dinner. Petruchio agrees that they should. Then he declares her his goods and his chattels, draws his sword on the company as if they were robbers, and takes her away. He does not argue with her refusal. He behaves as though it had not been made, and uses his legal rights as a husband to do the rest. From this point Katharina does not win another open confrontation.

The Very Name of Meat

At his country house Petruchio’s control becomes physical, though still without a blow. The supper comes in and he throws it out, explaining to his hungry wife that it is for her own good.

Original
I tell thee, Kate, 'twas burnt and dried away;
And I expressly am forbid to touch it,
For it engenders choler, planteth anger...

(Petruchio, Act 4, Scene 1)

Shakespeare Retold (Modern Verse)
I tell you, Kate, the meat was burnt and dry;
And I’ve been told that I must never touch it,
For indigestion always makes me angry...

Burnt meat breeds choler, and they are both choleric already, so they will fast. The reasoning is absurd and cannot be answered, because it is offered as care. This is the heart of his method. He does not forbid her to eat. He protects her from bad food, from a badly made bed, from an unfashionable gown, until she has had neither food nor sleep. Two scenes later she is reduced to begging his servant for something to eat, and the servant teases her with dishes he will not bring.

Original
Go, get thee gone, thou false deluding slave,
That feed'st me with the very name of meat...

(Katharina, Act 4, Scene 3)

Shakespeare Retold (Modern Verse)
Get out of here, you cheating little slave,
Who merely feeds me with the names of meat.

She beats him, which is the last time she uses force on anyone. To be fed "with the very name of meat" is a good description of her whole situation. She is being given the words for things, love, care, kindness, and not the things themselves.

What I List

The final ground of the contest is reality itself. On the road to Padua, in full daylight, Petruchio admires the moon. Katharina says it is the sun. He stops the horses.

Original
Now, by my mother's son, and that's myself,
It shall be moon, or star, or what I list...

(Petruchio, Act 4, Scene 5)

Shakespeare Retold (Modern Verse)
Now, by my mother’s son, i.e. myself,
It’s going to be the moon, or star, as I say...

It shall be the moon, or a star, or "what I list", whatever he pleases, before they go a step further. He has controlled what she eats and when she sleeps; now he claims the right to say what she sees. Her companion urges her to give in, and she does, in a speech that goes further than she was asked.

Original
Forward, I pray, since we have come so far,
And be it moon, or sun, or what you please:
An if you please to call it a rush-candle,
Henceforth I vow it shall be so for me.

(Katharina, Act 4, Scene 5)

Shakespeare Retold (Modern Verse)
Then carry on, please, since we’ve come this far,
And it can be the moon or sun, as you choose.
And if you want to say that it’s a candle,
Then from this moment on, that’s what I’ll call it.

Moon, sun, a "rush-candle": she will call it anything. It can be played as the collapse of a tired woman who wants to get home. It can also be played as the moment she sees that the whole thing is a game about words, and decides to play it better than he does. Either way the fight is over. The theme of illusion vs reality asks what it means to agree that the sun is the moon.

"Instead of beating Kate, he resorts to more civilized coercion: public humiliation at their wedding, starvation, sleep deprivation, and verbal bullying, all administered with the utmost courtesy and pretended kindness."

— Karen Newman, A Modern Perspective: The Taming of the Shrew, Folger Shakespeare Library

Key Quotes on Power and Control

Quote 1

Sirs, I will practise on this drunken man.
(Lord, Induction, Scene 1)

Shakespeare Retold (Modern Verse)
I’ll play a prank upon this drunken man, sirs.

Quote Analysis: The Lord, on finding Sly asleep. To "practise on" someone is to play a trick on them, and the word has an edge of experiment. A rich man with time on his hands decides to see what he can make a poor one believe. It is the play’s first exercise of power for its own sake, and it comes before Petruchio has been heard of. The taming of Katharina is watched, in the fiction, by a man who is himself being managed.

Quote 2

PETRUCHIO: I will not go to-day; and ere I do,
It shall be what o'clock I say it is.
HORTENSIO: Why, so this gallant will command the sun.

(Act 4, Scene 3)

Shakespeare Retold (Modern Verse)
PETRUCHIO: I will not go today; before I go,
It will be at the time I say it is.
HORTENSIO: My goodness, this man will command the sun.

Quote Analysis: Petruchio has said it is seven o’clock; Katharina has pointed out that it is nearly two. His reply is that the journey is off, and that whenever they do go it will be whatever time he says. Hortensio’s aside puts it in a line: this man will be giving orders to the sun next. The joke looks forward to the very next scene on the road, where that is exactly what he does.

Quote 3

Katharina, that cap of yours becomes you not:
Off with that bauble, throw it under-foot.

(Petruchio, Act 5, Scene 2)

Shakespeare Retold (Modern Verse)
Katharina, that hat doesn’t suit you:
So take it off and throw it on the ground.

Quote Analysis: Petruchio at the feast, after Katharina has come at his call. He wants a second proof for the company, and chooses a pointless one: she is to take off her cap and tread on it. She does. The order has no purpose except to show that she will obey an order with no purpose. The Widow and Bianca are disgusted, and it is their reaction, as much as Katharina’s obedience, that the scene is built to show.

Quote 4

Petruchio, go thy ways; the field is won.
(Hortensio, Act 4, Scene 5)

Shakespeare Retold (Modern Verse)
Petruchio, let it go; you’ve won your battle.

Quote Analysis: Hortensio on the road, when Katharina has agreed that the sun is the moon. "The field" is a battlefield. He speaks as a spectator who has watched a campaign and seen the enemy surrender, and he assumes without question that a marriage is a war that one side must win. It is the view of most of the men in the play. Whether it is the play’s view is another matter.

Key Takeaways

  • Changing the Ground: Katharina wins with words, so Petruchio moves the contest to things words cannot settle: contracts, food, sleep.
  • Control as Kindness: Everything he takes from her is taken for her own good, which leaves her nothing to argue against.
  • Naming the World: The last test is whether she will call the sun the moon, and so accept his account of what is real.
  • An Open Result: Her obedience at the end can be read as defeat or as a partnership in which she has learnt his game.

Study Questions and Analysis

How does Petruchio control Katharina without using violence?

By controlling what she needs and calling it love. He never hits her. He keeps her hungry and awake, and each time presents himself as the one person looking after her. When she has gone a day and a night without food, he comes in with a dish he has cooked himself.

Pluck up thy spirits; look cheerfully upon me.
Here love; thou see'st how diligent I am
To dress thy meat myself and bring it thee...

(Petruchio, Act 4, Scene 3)

Shakespeare Retold (Modern Verse)
Oh, cheer up; look at me, and then be happy.
Look here, my love, and see my diligence
Preparing all this food for you myself.

He has dressed her meat with his own hands. Then he waits. She says nothing, and he orders the dish taken away, since "the poorest service is repaid with thanks". She thanks him. Only then may she eat. The kindness and the control are the same act.

Karen Newman, in her "Modern Perspective" essay for the Folger edition, sets this beside the older shrew-taming stories, in which the husband simply beats his wife, and describes what Shakespeare put in its place: "Instead of beating Kate, he resorts to more civilized coercion: public humiliation at their wedding, starvation, sleep deprivation, and verbal bullying, all administered with the utmost courtesy and pretended kindness." She connects the change to humanist writers on marriage, who "recommend persuasion, not brutality, as the means of inculcating wifely obedience". Whether persuasion of this kind is an improvement is the question. George Bernard Shaw, in the Saturday Review in 1897, thought the process "quite bearable" because the man’s selfishness is "untainted by wanton cruelty". Emily Detmer, in Shakespeare Quarterly (1997), argued the opposite, that the play shows domination made more efficient: a husband who leaves no bruises cannot be accused of anything, and a wife who is thanked for thanking him has been taught to take part in her own subjection. Both readings start from the same observation, that Petruchio’s power works by removing the grounds for complaint. See Petruchio for the full character study.

Why does Petruchio take away the cap and gown?

To establish that what Katharina has is in his gift. The haberdasher brings a cap made to order, and Petruchio declares it too small. Katharina, for once, is specific about what she wants.

KATHARINA: I'll have no bigger: this doth fit the time,
And gentlewomen wear such caps as these.
PETRUCHIO: When you are gentle, you shall have one too,
And not till then.

(Act 4, Scene 3)

Shakespeare Retold (Modern Verse)
KATHARINA: I don’t want any bigger: it’s the fashion
And gentlewomen wear such caps as these.
PETRUCHIO: When you are gentle, you can have one too,
But not before then.

Gentlewomen wear such caps, she says. His answer turns on the word: when she is gentle she shall have one. It is a pun and a condition. Fashion, and the standing that goes with it, will be granted when she behaves as he wishes.

The exchange leads to her strongest speech of protest, in which she insists that she will speak her mind, and he responds by pretending she has agreed with him about the cap. That refusal to hear is the real exercise of power in the scene. Natasha Korda, in Shakespeare Quarterly (1996), observed that Petruchio never asks Katharina to work, and directs all his efforts at what she wants to own and wear: "He seeks to educate her in her role as a consumer." The gown is duly torn apart, and the tailor is quietly paid afterwards. So the scene is staged. Nothing is really wrong with the clothes, and Petruchio knows it. William Hazlitt, in Characters of Shakespear’s Plays (1817), enjoyed exactly this quality, describing a man with whom "a thing’s being plain and reasonable is a reason against it". A less amused reading is that Katharina is being shown, item by item, that reason has no purchase on him. The scene ends with the quarrel about the time, and the line that gives this theme its motto: it shall be what o’clock he says it is. The theme of class and status takes up what the plain clothes mean for her rank.

What part do the servants play in the taming?

They are his instruments and his audience. Petruchio rages at them in front of Katharina, and through them he carries out the business of keeping her hungry. When she asks Grumio to bring her some food, any food, he gives a servant’s answer.

No, no, forsooth; I dare not for my life.
(Grumio, Act 4, Scene 3)

Shakespeare Retold (Modern Verse)
No, no, I can’t; I dare not, for he’ll kill me.

He dares not. Whether he is truly afraid or is enjoying himself is hard to say, and probably both. He then offers her a neat’s foot, tripe, and beef with mustard, and withdraws each in turn. A servant is tormenting his mistress on his master’s orders, and she can do nothing but hit him.

The servants make visible something about power in the play, which is that it runs down a chain. The Lord in the Induction commands his huntsmen to deceive Sly. Petruchio commands Grumio, and Grumio lords it over Curtis and the rest. Karen Newman, in her "Modern Perspective" essay for the Folger edition, describes the thinking of the period in which "The family is represented as a little world organized like the larger world of the state", with husbands and masters as its rulers. Katharina’s place in that little world is what is being settled. She arrives at the house as its mistress and finds that the lowest man in it has more say over her dinner than she has. There is also a gentler effect. Watching Petruchio strike a servant for a trifle, she intervenes for the man: the fault was not intended. Some critics see in this the first sign that she is being changed by what she is shown, since she is now arguing for patience. One of the servants gives the plainest account of the method when he says that Petruchio "kills her in her own humour". He is doing to her, and in front of her, what she has done to others. See Katharina for the full character study.

Does Katharina have any power of her own?

At the beginning she has the power to frighten people, and it gets her nothing she wants. At the end she has something else. When the other wives refuse to come at the wager, she is sent to fetch them, and Petruchio announces her return.

See where she comes and brings your froward wives
As prisoners to her womanly persuasion.

(Petruchio, Act 5, Scene 2)

Shakespeare Retold (Modern Verse)
Look, here she comes with your unruly wives
Like prisoners to her womanly persuasion.

She brings them in "as prisoners". The woman who was carried off from her own wedding is now the one who compels. Her authority is borrowed from her husband, and she uses it on other women; but for the next forty-four lines nobody in the room interrupts her.

What kind of power this is has been much argued. Coppélia Kahn, in an essay of 1975, thought Katharina the real winner of the scene: she "steals the scene from her husband", and he "has gained her outward compliance in the form of a public display, while her spirit remains mischievously free". Germaine Greer, in The Female Eunuch (1970), saw strength of another sort, in a woman who gives up something real, and judged that her submission "is genuine and exciting because she has something to lay down". Karen Newman, in her "Modern Perspective" essay for the Folger edition, stresses the simple fact of her eloquence: she is "speaking forcefully and in public the longest speech in the play". A sceptic would answer that power exercised on a husband’s instruction, to win a husband’s bet, in praise of a husband’s rule, is not much of a gain. The play supports both sides. Katharina has learnt that open defiance fails and that performance succeeds, and by the end she is very good at performance. Whether that makes her free or merely skilled is the question the last scene leaves with us. The theme of gender and patriarchy sets it in its wider frame.

What does the wager prove?

That Katharina will come when she is called, and that the others will not. The form of the summons matters. Lucentio bids his wife come, Hortensio entreats his, and both are refused. Petruchio uses a different verb.

Sirrah Grumio, go to your mistress;
Say, I command her to come to me.

(Petruchio, Act 5, Scene 2)

Shakespeare Retold (Modern Verse)
Boy Grumio, go to your mistress;
Say I command that she should come to me.

"I command her." The other husbands laugh. They are sure that a command will fail where a request has failed. She comes at once, and the laughter stops.

On the face of it the scene is a demonstration that authority works and politeness does not. That is how the men on stage take it, and how George Bernard Shaw took it in 1897, when he wrote that no man could watch it with a woman "without being extremely ashamed of the lord-of-creation moral implied in the wager". Robert Heilman, in 1966, thought this too earnest, since "the whole wager scene falls essentially within the realm of farce" and its responses are mechanical. A third reading looks at what Petruchio risks. He bets heavily, in public, on something he cannot enforce: if she refuses, he is a laughing-stock. He is relying on her. On that view the wager shows a couple who have reached an understanding and are using it to beat everyone else at the table. Katharina certainly seems to enjoy her entrance. It is worth adding that the bet is made by husbands, about wives, for money, and that nobody asks the wives whether they wish to take part. The Widow and Bianca decline. Their refusal is the one exercise of power in the scene that owes nothing to a man. See Hortensio and Lucentio for the losing husbands.

Who holds the power at the end of the play?

Petruchio, by every outward sign. He has the obedient wife, the winnings and a second dowry. The other men are left staring.

LUCENTIO: Here is a wonder, if you talk of a wonder.
HORTENSIO: And so it is: I wonder what it bodes.

(Act 5, Scene 2)

Shakespeare Retold (Modern Verse)
LUCENTIO: This is amazing, if we talk of wonders.
HORTENSIO: And so it is: I wonder what comes next.

Lucentio calls it a wonder, and Hortensio wonders what it "bodes", what it means for the future. They speak of it as people speak of a portent, something outside the ordinary course of nature. Neither of them claims to understand it.

That bafflement is the play’s last word on power, and critics have read it in two directions. For some it confirms the victory: Petruchio has done what no one thought possible, and William Hazlitt (1817) could call the final scene "a very happy one", in which the trial of the wives ends "so triumphantly for Petruchio". For others the wonder is a doubt. The closing line, given to Lucentio, is that it is a wonder Katharina "will be tamed so", and "will" may mean that she chooses it. Harold Goddard, in The Meaning of Shakespeare (1951), took the view that the wife ends up governing the husband by letting him think he governs her, and refused to believe Shakespeare held "the wholly un-Shakespearean doctrine of male superiority". There is also the frame to reckon with. The whole contest has been a play put on for Christopher Sly, a beggar whom a lord has tricked into thinking himself powerful, and the text never returns to show him undeceived. The most powerful figure in the story, on that view, is the one who arranged for it to be watched. The theme of illusion vs reality follows that thought. What the last scene shows for certain is two people leaving together, and a room full of others who cannot explain what they have seen.

James Anthony

James Anthony is an award-winning, multi-genre author from London, England. With a keen eye, sharp wit, and poetic irreverence, he retold all 154 of Shakespeare's sonnets in modern verse, published by Penguin Random House in 2018. Described by Stephen Fry as 'a dazzling success,' he continues to retell the Bard's greatest plays in his popular 'Shakespeare Retold' series. When not tackling the Bard, Anthony is an offbeat travel writer, documenting his trips in his 'Slow Road' series, earning him the moniker the English Bill Bryson. Anthony also performs globally as a solo tribute act to English political troubadour Billy Bragg.

https://www.james-anthony.com
Previous
Previous

Class and Status

Next
Next

Education and Transformation